-Diablo's Journal, 22 August 2019

How Low-Carb Diets Actually Work (Spoiler: It’s Not Insulin)

By Aadam on August 22, 2019

There’s nothing magic about low-carb diets. Here’s how they actually work.

1. Low-carb diets are high-protein diets

When you look at protein intake in two popular low-carb diets versus the recommended daily intake:



The low-carb diets have ~3x the amount of protein. And high-protein diets reduce appetite which can lead to people eating less.



2. They reduce calorie density

Calorie density is the number of calories in a serving of food. Foods with a lower calorie density provide fewer calories per gram than foods with a higher calorie density.

Example: 100g apple versus 100g chocolate



Calorie density has been linked to an increase in body weight, while a reduction in calorie density has shown to decrease body weight.



When people adopt a low-carb diet they inadvertently swap heavily processed calorie-dense foods for minimally processed whole foods.



This means they consume and feel satiated on fewer calories which leads to a reduction in total calories consumed.

3. They reduce food variety

Food intake increases when there’s more variety in the diet (did someone say buffet?) and greater dietary variety is associated with increased body weight and fat.



By cutting out an entire food group, people are limited to what they can eat (the high-calorie, heavily processed foods) which leads to–yep, you guessed it–a reduction in calorie intake.

All of these factors cause people to improve the quality of their diet which leads to a reduction in calorie intake (are you noticing a pattern here?), which leads to fat loss, which leads to improved energy and better health.

But you can apply these same principles without eliminating carbs.

• Increase protein intake at every meal, including snacks. Aim for between 20-40g per meal.

• Reduce the calorie density of your diet by swapping heavily processed foods for nutrient-dense minimally processed foods.



• Reduce diet variety by selecting fewer foods and making them the foundation of your diet (not every meal has to be Instagram-worthy).

Ultimately, the ‘type’ of diet you follow matters far less than your ability to stick to the diet for the long-term.

And all sensible diets, regardless of their fancy name or macro composition, follow the same overarching principles: calorie-controlled. Limited ultra-processed foods. With an emphasis on whole, nutrient-dense foods.

Focus on these principles while eating in a way you enjoy–including the foods you enjoy–and you’ll be ok.

If you want to try a low-carb diet, go for it.

You should experiment to find a way of eating that suits you best. But choose to do something knowing why you’re doing it versus out of fear or unfounded claims by a misinformed dweeb on the internet.

http://physiqonomics.com/how-low-carb-diets-work/

Diet Calendar Entries for 22 August 2019:
2854 kcal Fat: 78.65g | Prot: 184.68g | Carb: 436.16g.   Breakfast: Pure Protein Chocolate Peanut Butter High Protein Bar (Small), Trader Joe's Bread & Butter Pickles, Carl Buddig Deli Thin Honey Turkey Lunch Meat, Ole Extreme Wellness Spinach & Herbs Tortilla Wraps, Fit Crunch Chocolate Peanut Butter, Ole Extreme Wellness High Fiber Low Carb Tortillas, Wal-Mart 93/7 Lean Ground Beef , Pears, Chobani Strawberry Blended Greek Yogurt. Lunch: Taquitos with Meat, Pears, Halo Top Creamery Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream, Peach, Quest Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Protein Bar, Bananas . Dinner: Syrup. more...
3929 kcal Activities & Exercise: Running (jogging) - 5/mph - 15 minutes, Sleeping - 7 hours and 40 minutes, Sitting - 8 hours, Weight Training (moderate) - 1 hour and 45 minutes, Bicycling (leisurely) - <10/mph - 2 hours and 35 minutes, Resting - 3 hours and 45 minutes. more...

17 Supporters    Support   

Comments 
Feeling like the illegitimate child of keto by bringing up cico.  
22 Aug 19 by member: moopie321
Aren't you more low carb than keto now? :) Baby steps, soon you'll be bulking like Chris. Just kidding lol 
22 Aug 19 by member: -Diablo
This week I averaged 36 g of net carbs/ day. I think last week I may have doubled that. So kinda keto? 
22 Aug 19 by member: moopie321
Nothing like learning about low carb from a carb eater­. Now if you think I will visit a doctor when I need a dentist, it will never happen! 
22 Aug 19 by member: Ireland-83
Anyway, kind of related to this article, has anyone ever thought about the effect of going low carb diets and food weight? Let's say a vegan who eats a lot of fruits and veggies goes to keto for example. Won't they lose some weight after a couple of days by eating fewer grams of food? As an example, the average piece of fruit weighs about 200 grams. That is almost half a pound for about 80 calories. Now, how many calories would 200 grams of bacon be? I just checked and it would be 1082 calories. That's 13.5 times more calories. Food weight and water weight affects day to day fluctuations. I think that going keto from vegan or high carb would not only reduce your weight due to losing glycogen, but you'd also lose weight from less food in the gut/intestines. Also, this can help explain weighing less after a cheat day sometimes. You may have gone overboard on calories but the food you did eat may weigh less. A double quarter pounder is 1/2 a pound. The same as a large apple that has 1/4 of the calories. I know fruit and vegetable contain water but still. A pound of lean meat vs. a pound of cheese or bacon may be a better example. 
22 Aug 19 by member: -Diablo
Ireland, I've done low carb. I've been dieting and reading about health and fitness since 2000. If there were some advantage to LC other than less energy in than out, I would be on the LC train. I like to optimize my diet and weight lifting. I definitely wouldn't be missing out on the benefits. There are just zero benefits for me. Also, these aren't my words, hence the link at the bottom. 
22 Aug 19 by member: -Diablo
Of course, someone who has a private bio, weight, diet calendar, and has a wine bottle as a profile pic may know better. :P 
22 Aug 19 by member: -Diablo
I’m low carb... kinda keto. Would the words mean something else if I posted it?  
22 Aug 19 by member: moopie321
Nah, let's listen to a doctors pseudoscience(designed to sell books) over lean people who eat carbs which should prove it isn't the carbs, but the calories. Lean people who don't profit monetarily from spreading BS like these doctors and other diet gurus. 
23 Aug 19 by member: -Diablo
I was asked today what I didn’t get regarding insulin and weight gain. He said it’s clear it’s insulin causing it. If it’s the number of spikes causing the weight gain, reducing the number of meals would reduce the number of spikes and therefore reduce my weight... but I gained. If it’s the intensity of the insulin spike from food, then keto foods which are low carb would produce the least amount of insulin response (I was provided a chart from idk where) then keto dieters should not be able to gain... During fasting with no insulin spikes you’re not eating, 0 calories in while the body is still burning energy to maintain life, CICO. His response “smh” 
23 Aug 19 by member: moopie321
I’m done. Going to post food pics and catmemes haha 
23 Aug 19 by member: moopie321
@Ireland Do you struggle with your weight ? 
23 Aug 19 by member: rosio19
If it's the insulin, I should be one of the heaviest members here. I snack all night at work on insulin raising foods. People used to eat 6-8 meals a day to lose weight and it worked, now OMAD(one meal a day) is gaining steam. Which is it? Oh, it doesn't matter as long as calories are accounted for? Great. 
23 Aug 19 by member: -Diablo
When asked if keto was a safe life long diet a nutrition coach that is in this nutrition group I am part of said, "I don't think it's unhealthy in the long term,. But some people can develop a condition called keto zealotry which makes you adopt pseudoscientific beliefs and make you feel like a superior human being. Be careful."----I found that to be hilarious and on point. 
23 Aug 19 by member: -Diablo
The first 4 months of my journey ( back in may of 2018 when I weighed 283 lbs) I was doing keto strict, no more than 20 net grams of carbs a day. I lost weight. Come September/Oct of 2018 I started adding carbs in, because I joined a gym and started resistance training. Guess what? I continued losing weight, with carbs in my diet, but still at a deficit. Who would have thought. To this day I eat carbs, and I am still maintaining a 90 something lb loss. Just to prove it was the calorie deficit not the carbs. I liked eating both ways, not gonna lie, but I have 100% better performance in the gym with carbs than without. Hell, my best workouts I noticed come right after I go above my calorie intake for the day! Good article! 
23 Aug 19 by member: Kennyn27
Just to add this, my body composition at 190 lbs untrained verse my carb filled body trained at 190 lbs is drastically different. And I have photos to prove this! It's the same weight, but a night and day difference. I'll post them soon. 
23 Aug 19 by member: Kennyn27
Thank you for your story, Kennyn! Carbohydrates seem to be a great macro for body composition since they provide optimal energy to push yourself which is my focus and also should be important to everyone in my opinion. The better your muscle to fat ratio the healthier you are(to a point of course). It is interesting to keep hearing this even among people who used to be keto. I keep hearing from some keto dieters that fat works just as well but I see many reports that refute that. 
23 Aug 19 by member: -Diablo

     
 

Submit a Comment


You must  sign in to submit a comment
 

Other Related Links

Members



-Diablo's weight history


Get the app
    
© 2024 FatSecret. All rights reserved.