Banting diet not working

previous topic · next topic

Joined: Jun 16
Posts: 1

Posted: 06 Nov 2019, 03:11
Hi there. I've been on the banting diet for a month now and the weight is not budging! I don't know what to do anymore... Sad

I had tests done and there's nothing wrong with me. I tried shakes, potions, starving, exercised myself to death and nothing is happening!

Banting was my last option and even that is not working for me.

I'm a female, 38years old. My weight has been gradually increasing the past 3 years. I have 20kg's to lose.

Anyone with some advice?

Joined: Oct 09
Posts: 1,088

Posted: 06 Nov 2019, 08:05
Do you log everything. Do you eat enough real food

Joined: Apr 09
Posts: 217

Posted: 06 Nov 2019, 09:27
Hang in there. Are you weighing your food and really tracking everything you are eating? I was not losing weight and finally realized that I had "forgotten" to log the snacks I was having just before bed.
Every day is a new day.

Joined: Oct 12
Posts: 450

Posted: 06 Nov 2019, 14:47
wow you must be a scientific miracle ………………………...or your not being honest with yourself or us...………….weight doesn't increase by itself you can be in 3 states only....weight loss- weight maintainance- weight gain all are dictated by your caloric intake vs caloric output nothing else

Joined: Apr 11
Posts: 106

Posted: 20 Nov 2019, 10:06
While spacey48's advice is unnecessarily sarcastic, he/she is getting at the right thing.

If you're gaining weight, you are eating more calories than you are burning. Start honestly logging and weighing everything that you're eating and drinking and you'll undoubtedly see that.

I strongly recommend giving up the fad diets and doing things to extreme - it's not sustainable. The only reason these diets and shakes may work at times is because they achieve a calorie deficit through some kind of restriction. There's no secret hack in them and no magic bullet. They're making you do crazy things to achieve that deficit though, it's hit and miss because there's no proper logging with those diets (they rely on rules rather than logging) and, really, it's all completely unnecessary - there are much easier, more satisfying and more sustainable ways of achieving a deficit.

Your diet should just be about good nutrition and foods you enjoy - a way of eating that you would be happy to stick with for the foreseeable future and that keeps you within a calorie budget that you set. Aim for a reasonable calorie deficit, be diligent with logging/weighing your food to ensure you're on track, get enough sleep and drink lots of water. It doesn't need to be more complicated than that. You certainly don't need to cut out any food groups.

Stop looking for quick fixes, design for the long term and be reasonable with your expectations.

Forum Search
Advanced forum search

Latest Posts

Milk has a lot of lactose... So that does it. You can lower calories by choosing lower fats. a cup of skim will have about 60 fewer calories than a cup of whole milk
by liv001 on 10 Dec 19 08:47 AM
5' 7" - 5' 8" What is you CW & GW ?
Hey, I saw an interesting post for 5"3 - 5' 4" to list there CW and/or GW... I thought it would be interesting to get the same perspective of my own height range... :) Remember... we all ...
by Melody-24 on 09 Dec 19 12:06 PM
You know, everyone looses incentive at some point. Often when we find ourselves taking a step forward we end up taking two... or even ten steps backwards... but the key is having a dream - why are you ...
by Melody-24 on 09 Dec 19 10:58 AM
Que bueno y satisfactorio es saber que debes subir de peso cuando hace 3 meses llegaste a pesar 18 kilos más que tu rango, y ahora me han dicho que este puede ser un mes de relax, pero no completo, ...
by GuilleAguayo on 08 Dec 19 11:58 AM
I really stuck...
When I get "stuck" I just stop feeling sorry for myself and jump up on the horse again. It's not fun, but it keeps me from falling back into old, stupid habits. I deserve to feel good about ...
by dlilli on 07 Dec 19 04:11 PM

Get the app
© 2019 FatSecret. All rights reserved.