previous topic · next topic

Joined: Jan 12
Posts: 4

Posted: 07 Jul 2013, 09:04
I am doing Atkins for a little over one year now and have lost 138 pounds. My initial goal was to reach high school weight of 175 pounds. I am 5'11" tall imagine my surprise upon investigation even at 175 pounds I would be considered slightly overweight body mass index says I should way between 132 pounds and 172 pounds. Would just like to get some feedback how serious does anyone take these numbers. I am feeling now even at 175 pounds I will look drastically thin maybe even to the point of looking ill; can imagine what I would look like at 132 pounds

Joined: Jan 13
Posts: 994

Posted: 07 Jul 2013, 09:13
Congrats on the massive weight loss. As to the BMI, each to their own. Personally, I would go with what you feel comfortable with. Hubby weighs 200 and is considered overweight at 6'. Ridiculous, isn't it?

Just do what feels right for you and don't worry about the BMI. if you're off meds and doing well, you're successful.

Remember, these numbers for BMI are a general figure and definitely can't be applied to the masses. We're all different. Small bone, large bone.

Joined: Sep 11
Posts: 894

Posted: 07 Jul 2013, 11:06
I believe critics of the BMI measurement state that it does not take into account the amount of muscle an individual may be carrying.

Congratulations on the weight loss!!!!

Joined: Nov 11
Posts: 959

Posted: 07 Jul 2013, 11:18
Yeah, BMI is junk science at best. I mean, it is awesome to beat them at their own measurements system but in the end whatever weight *you* feel comfortable at is the one to go with.

By the way, have you measured your frame size? It only requires a measuring tape. Here is how to do that:

...and here is a table for weight based on sex, height and frame size:


Joined: Nov 11
Posts: 959

Posted: 07 Jul 2013, 11:19
And!! Wow! That is awesome that you've lost so much weight!! Congratulations!!

Joined: Apr 12
Posts: 916

Posted: 07 Jul 2013, 14:03
Think Body fat percentage not BMI , get into a healthy range for your age and your set

Joined: Feb 10
Posts: 123

Posted: 05 Jan 2016, 08:33
*throws the BMI thing out the window and curses*
Las Vegas...

Joined: Feb 11
Posts: 8

Posted: 01 Jun 2016, 16:57
As a nurse I can tell you that most of our height/weight/BMI charts have been skewed by the large number of obese people that go into it. That being said, you need to be practical. That 132 - 172 is a range. If you are small boned, you should be closer to the lower figure. If you are large boned, then you should be closer to the higher figure. Also don't forget you are used to seeing your fat self and so may look emaciated to yourself now. The important thing is that you feel healthy and comfortable with the way you look. The charts are just a guideline. If you feel good, look good and your MD says you are healthy then just start maintaining. I am so impressed with you. It has taken me far longer to lose my 120 pounds with many setbacks. I think I might try your 'less than 20 carbs' and see if I can stick to that for awhile so that I can lose more than 1/2 - 1 pound a week. All I can say again is CONGRATULATIONS!!! You are my hero Smile

Joined: Apr 16
Posts: 8

Posted: 01 Jun 2016, 19:01
BMI is a ration between the amount of fat related to your muscular tissue, so no matter how much your weight is you might still have high BMI. The best way is to start working out to increase your muscular tissue in relation to body fat to have optimal BMI.

Forum Search
Advanced forum search

Latest Posts

Scales at home
I finally got a new scale that matches the doctor's office exactly. I would just use the weight on the scale at home and know that the doctor's office will show more OR get a new scale - but it ...
by Fritzy 22 on 23 Apr 18 06:28 PM
Climbing my way out of a very deep sorrow
Losing weight is so hard, even when life is going perfectly. My hat's off to all of you who soldier on through life's trials and tribulations.
by ValerieJN on 23 Apr 18 10:57 AM
BMR with activity factor
“Technically” yes. 1400 calories is a good number for you to start with. We don’t know how much you actually burn. The number FS gives you is approximation and it tends to be on the high side. Still with ...
by Ingria on 21 Apr 18 04:49 PM
You are very welcome. I'm glad you got the answer to your question.
by teskandar on 21 Apr 18 04:02 PM
How many carbs do you need aday
by nanapapyll82 on 21 Apr 18 09:57 AM