Reducing Net Carbs with Fiber Supplement. Is it possible?

previous topic · next topic
Blackeyes24

Joined: Nov 10
Posts: 36

      quote  
Posted: 19 Feb 2013, 09:41
Does anyone know if I added some benefiber to my yogurt if it would reduce the net carbs (carbs minus fiber=net carbs) the same way it does when there is naturally occuring fiber in the food? I'm calorie counting and concentrating on increasing my protein and reducing (not eliminating) my carbs. This seems like it would work but I dont know enough about it to be sure. Confused
liv001

Joined: Oct 09
Posts: 676

      quote  
Posted: 19 Feb 2013, 09:57
No
There is no way to reduce carbs like that
If you add something that has fiber it automatically has carbs - because fiber is carbs - so it only cancels itself out.
ghechr

Joined: Nov 12
Posts: 8

      quote  
Posted: 19 Feb 2013, 10:18
No. Let's say your yogurt has 15g carbs and 0g fiber. You add benefiber, which is 10g carbs, 5 of which is fiber. So what you're eating has 25g carbs and 5g fiber for a net carb of 20g. If you didn't add the benefiber, you'd have 15g carbs, 0g fiber. (I just made up these numbers but you get the idea.)
mrspackrat

Joined: Aug 10
Posts: 557

      quote  
Posted: 19 Feb 2013, 11:55
I agree with ghechr---you can reduce your carbs with fiber (which is your net carbs). My yogurt has 18g of carbs, 1 serving of my powder supplement has 4g of carbs, 3 of which are fiber. Total carbs is 22g but net carbs is 19g (22-3).
eKatherine

Joined: Aug 12
Posts: 1,286

      quote  
Posted: 19 Feb 2013, 13:11
The issue is that even plain yogurt is a high carb food. The individual servings in the sugar-sweetened varieties have as much sugar as dessert.

Buy plain yogurt and wean yourself off the sweetening a little bit each day. Or eat smaller portions. Half a serving will only have half the carbs. Eat it with an egg.
mrspackrat

Joined: Aug 10
Posts: 557

      quote  
Posted: 19 Feb 2013, 13:33
Yogurt was just the example, you can use fiber to reduce carbs from vegetables. I think the poster was just wanting to know if fiber will help get to a lower net carb which is yes.
eKatherine

Joined: Aug 12
Posts: 1,286

      quote  
Posted: 19 Feb 2013, 13:41
mrspackrat wrote:
Yogurt was just the example, you can use fiber to reduce carbs from vegetables. I think the poster was just wanting to know if fiber will help get to a lower net carb which is yes.


Adding fiber to your diet will not reduce your net carbs, even in your own example.

18 grams of net carbs plus 1 gram from your supplement = 19 grams of net carbs. The arithmetic still works.
ghechr

Joined: Nov 12
Posts: 8

      quote  
Posted: 19 Feb 2013, 16:30
mrspackrat wrote:
Yogurt was just the example, you can use fiber to reduce carbs from vegetables. I think the poster was just wanting to know if fiber will help get to a lower net carb which is yes.


No, it won't. Whenever you add fiber to something, you are adding carbohydrates to it. So if you add 10g fiber to, let's say, water, you are increasing the carbohydrates in the water from 0g to 10g. Assuming every gram is fiber (often it is not with a fiber supplement so be careful) you get 10g - 10g = zero, which is the original amount of carbs in the item you added the fiber too.
mrspackrat

Joined: Aug 10
Posts: 557

      quote  
Posted: 20 Feb 2013, 08:30
To clarify, NO you cannot reduce NET carbs, my example was to show how to reduce total carbs to get NET carbs. I believe the poster used the wrong term but maybe she didn't.

The Net Carb number reflects the grams of carbohydrate that significantly impacts your blood sugar level. Yes, fiber has carbs but for some of us, we are just concentrating on net carbs (total carbs - fiber). In the water/fiber supplement example, my water - 0 carbs, fiber supplement 4g carbs - total carbs 4g. Fiber is 3g carbs so my NET carbs = 1g vs the original 4g of carbs.
ebivr

Joined: Jun 08
Posts: 438

      quote  
Posted: 20 Feb 2013, 08:57
The carb reduces because it's taking away the fibre not because it's taking away the net carbs. The net carbs ALWAYS remain the same. Total carbs is just net carbs + fibre. While net carbs is just carbs WITHOUT fibre. If you add fibre you are increasing your total carbs but you're net carbs still remain the same.

Net carbs is sugar & starch, you still have the same amount of sugar & starch in the food regardless of whether you have fibre in it or not.
"Do what thou wilt shall be the the Law, Love is the whole of the law, Love before will, The meaning of life is to Love"
"Never apologise for who you are"
"Leave as little negative impact on the world as possible"
"Last night fear knocked on my door, faith answered and no one was there"
Even if it's slow it's going to Go!

Starting weight: 318 lbs!! 2nd of June 2008 (Calorie Counting!).

June 08 Month 1: 298 lb (20 lb. lost). July 08 Month 2: 291 lb (7 lb. lost). August 08 Month 3: 279 lb (12 lb. lost). September 08 Month 4: 268 lb (11 lb. lost). October 08 Month 5: 257 lb (11 lb. lost). November 08 Month 6: 248 lb (9 lb. lost). December 08 Month 7: 235 lb (13 lb. lost).

January 2009 Month 8: 229 lb (6 lb. lost). February 09 Month 9: 223 lb (6 lb. lost). March 09 Month 10: 211 lb (12 lb. lost). April 09 Month 11: 208 lb (3 lb. lost). May 09 Month 12: 210 lb (+2 lb. gained). June 09 Month 13: 188 lb (22 lb. lost). July 09 Month 14: 181 lb (7 lb. lost). August 09 Month 15: 179 lb (2 lb. lost).

DO OVER!!
Starting weight: 295.6 lb!! 11th of August 2014 (Atkins!).

September 2014. Month 1: 287.8 lb (7.8 lb. lost).



Forum Search
Advanced forum search


Latest Posts

High carb- Low protein and HUNGRY all the time???
wholefoodnut wrote: Fat secret food system does not calculate complementary proteins. So if you are combining beans/legumes with seeds/nuts or whole grains or combining any of them you are getting more ...
by Hannahan on 20 Sep 14 12:48 AM
Fed Up (2014) Documentary
nb girl wrote: 7Priest7, did you actually see the movie? Yes nb girl wrote: The movie showed a 6 month old baby who is obese, you could argue the mother is overfeeding the baby, but as the obstetrician ...
by 7Priest7 on 19 Sep 14 09:45 PM
Health sidekick
Yup looked into it too and it doesn't follow the golden rule of KISS (keep it simple stupid) It was confusing, plus the food data base was weird. MFS is global and they have done a great job of ...
by AKRSAR on 19 Sep 14 06:39 PM
Eliminating Sugar - Where do you draw the line?
Ruhu wrote: I know not all agree that eliminating sugar is the way to go for us self-proclaimed sugar addicts, but it truly works best for me. I've found time & time again that for me, one bite ...
by rolandbaranek on 19 Sep 14 12:57 PM
exercise
If adding it yourself is too much, go to the exercise list. There are calisthenics in 2 or 3 levels as well as yoga (for stretching type things). I use the light calisthenics since I do them at home and ...
by msbuggirl on 19 Sep 14 11:48 AM