Have to get off Atkins and my Dr. suggested South Beach

previous topic · next topic

Joined: Dec 10
Posts: 11

Posted: 19 Apr 2011, 17:58
Wondering if anyone can tell me the basic differences between these two diets. My chloresteral (sp) has gone way up during the last four months on Atkins so he suggested this might be a better alternative.Thank you! (My weight is good right now but I don't want to gain it all back. So I need a maintenance plan. Thanks again.

Joined: Mar 11
Posts: 65

Posted: 19 Apr 2011, 18:38
I think both are very similar. Both are low carb diets, but South Beach usually suggests lower fat alternatives. Atkins would say chicken with skin on, South beach says skinless. Atkins says bacon, SB says turkey bacon. I think SB is based on glycemic index.... It will probably be pretty easy to switch, without weight gain.
"Being fat is hard. Losing weight is hard. Pick your hard."

Joined: Apr 11
Posts: 27

Posted: 20 Apr 2011, 17:39
Hi, Jane. Smile

Here is a description of the South Beach diet from


About the author: Dr. Arthur Agatston is an MD with a practice in the South Beach area of Miami, hence the name. He is also Associate Professor of Internal Medicine at University of Miami, and has published >100 scientific medical articles.

Basic Philosophy: The diet has evolved since the writing of the book, especially regarding dairy and some common vegetables such as carrots. Even before the diet changes, the major part of the book and the recipes contradicted each other at times – the recipes seem to be written by someone more familiar with the low fat traditional diet (e.g.: eggs are ok according to the book, but egg substitute is recommended for recipes).

The small guide is useful for later stages, to determine which fruits and vegetables are not recommended, but does not distinguish between phases 1 and 2 and can’t be used without either the book or an online description of the major ideas of the plan. Just eating unlimited amounts of “good” foods from the guide will not work.

Eating good carbs and good fats spread over 6 meals/snacks a day will balance blood levels of glucose, insulin, cholesterol and other coronary heart disease (CHD) markers. While the author claims that the diet is neither low carb nor low fat, it really is generally a high protein, high fiber, low carb and low animal fat diet.

This diet was initially developed to help prediabetic and/or heart disease patients with high levels of (bad) cholesterol and triglycerides as well as glucose levels. Weight loss was a side effect that prompted the writing up of the prescribed diet into the book. Thus, the main thrust of this plan is to keep glucose and insulin levels even, and to lower (bad) cholesterol and triglycerides. Weight loss should follow automatically.

This is achieved by completely avoiding refined carbohydrates that are quickly absorbed and high on the glycemic index, and by avoiding man-made trans fatty acids as well as saturated animal fats. No references cited for the exclusion of saturated fats.

Eating eggs, fish, seafood, chicken or turkey breast, lean ham, nearly all vegetables and drinking lots of water is encouraged, as well as moderate amounts of nearly all fruits, nuts, other low fat meats, whole grain bread, pasta and rice, olive or canola oil and a glass of red wine a day. Not allowed are any products containing sugar, fruit juices, potatoes, refined grains (bread, pasta, white rice), regular diary, fatter cuts of beef, poultry and pork, butter, and beer.

By the numbers: : Eat 3 meals and 3 snacks a day. Never go hungry. No counting of calories, fats or carbohydrates (restricted in Phase 1). Eat of the allowed until you feel full but not stuffed.

Method: Phase 1 is the strictest and is suggested for the first 2 weeks. It is also suggested to return to phase 1 after cheats. In phase 1, no fruit, alcohol or whole grain carbohydrate is allowed – only fish, eggs, lean meats, limited low fat diary and leafy vegetables are eaten – though no carbohydrates are counted.

In phase 2, fruit, nuts, whole grain products, red wine if desired are added gradually. It is recommended to add one such product at a time and to see what happens before adding more.

Phase 3 or maintenance has no forbidden foods – it is expected that one follows the principles that were learned in the plan for life in general, but exceptions are allowed.

Typical menu: About a third of the book are menus and recipes.

Breakfast small glass vegetable juice, a vegetable quiche (based on eggs, spinach, onion, other vegetables and low fat cheese).
Midmorning snack: celery with low fat cheese
Lunch Large vegetable salad with shrimps or chicken breast
Snack low fat string cheese, nuts
Dinner Salmon with asparagus
Dessert/evening snack: low fat ricotta dessert with artificial sweetener and fruit
Unique Fatures: Because of the hybrid nature between traditional low fat diets and Atkins, South Beach is more acceptable for traditional nutritioonists and medical professionals. Without counting calories, fat, or carbs, it may seem generous and somewhat subjective: in phase 2, one is instructed to gradually add new items and watch what happens. Because of the stress on glucose, timing can be important, e.g. fruit is allowed in the evening but not morning. Cheating is somewhat expected. For example, while potatoes are not allowed, there is a discussion which preparation of potatoes is worst and which the least offensive.

Hope that helps a bit. Smile

Forum Search
Advanced forum search

Latest Posts

Sugar actually MORE addicting than cocaine and heroine...
Exactly Phil, with regard to avoiding all forms of sugar. Which makes the detox all that much harder! Because that also includes artificial sweeteners...! That first study I linked in the original ...
by Roobert on 26 Oct 16 01:16 PM
break down recipes
fatsecret has this in the section call "My Cook Book" in your My FatSecret page. You put in your ingredients and the number of servings and it will calculate all that for you.
by abbadabba on 26 Oct 16 12:37 PM
Why you don't lose weight?
[quote=puhpine1][url=https://e... ?????
by spacey48 on 26 Oct 16 05:28 AM
Can't seem to stick to a diet
Nothing wrong in eating a pizza, it's just a case of how much and how often
by spacey48 on 26 Oct 16 02:57 AM
By the way, congrats on the 8kgs, that's awesome!
by gutstogo on 24 Oct 16 09:50 PM

Member Tip

average member ranking
by member Sharon Caulkins
eat regularly
07 Jun 13 for diet The South Beach Diet