Atkins - Why did I gain?

previous topic · next topic
szqnva

Joined: Jul 09
Posts: 38

      quote  
Posted: 10 Aug 2009, 07:52
Yikes!! I am on Atkins and doing very well at sticking to the right amount of carbs. Was losing at a great pace, but got on the scale today and gained 3 lbs!!! What's up with this? I notice I did have an increase in calories for a couple days, although my net carbs were right on. Is this supposed to happen, or do I need to start watching my calories too?
JeffS

Joined: Jul 09
Posts: 11

      quote  
Posted: 10 Aug 2009, 09:20
I did Atkins previously and had great success with the loss(50+), but never quite got to goal, and never was able to maintain.

I do clearly remember that after the initial 3 weeks or so the weight very unpredictable except on a week or two week basis. I primarily attributed it to hydration changes. When this was happening I felt like I was losing the fat, but gaining water. My clothes were continuing to get looser, even though weight was increasing.

And yes, as you lose, you will be burning less energy every day, and you will have to be conscious of the calories you eat if you want to continue to drop weight.
mountain_mam...

Joined: Aug 09
Posts: 83

      quote  
Posted: 10 Aug 2009, 16:43
I've been on the Atkin's nutritional approach since mid-April. If you looked at my weight chart it resembles a downward sloping zig zag. My pattern is to lose weight to a new low, immediately climb back up 2-3 lbs and start working my way down until that new low is my new average then repeat the cycle. I will often go 2 weeks without losing any new weight then drop 1-2 lbs.

This is actually very average. I have lost at a weekly .84 lb average. That's low-medium as most people vary between .5-2 lbs per week.

Colette, the official nutritionist at the Atkins Message Board has said, "We lose in fits and starts." Sometimes we've eaten too much salt and are retaining water-weight, the weather is hot and sticky and we retain water-weight, it's our TOM (time of the month) or our body just decides to be obnoxious because it can Smile

Hang in there!
Audrey
szqnva

Joined: Jul 09
Posts: 38

      quote  
Posted: 10 Aug 2009, 22:32
Thank you both for the encouragement. Maybe it is water weight. I just thought that during induction there would be this huge weight drop, so I'm a little discouraged and feel like I must not be doing something right. I'm still reading my Atkins book, though, so maybe that will help figure out what the problem is. If I'm going to gain weight...well, I might as well eat a dang gone doughnut!! I know that's not the way I should be thinking but I'm a little frustrated. sorry. Sad
mountain_mam...

Joined: Aug 09
Posts: 83

      quote  
Posted: 10 Aug 2009, 22:55
It's very common to lose a lot the first week a little the second and nothing for a couple of weeks. I've heard it over and over. Hang in there. Do everything right and it will eventually go away!
Audrey
szqnva

Joined: Jul 09
Posts: 38

      quote  
Posted: 11 Aug 2009, 08:56
Okay...I'm going to trust you on this! Smile



Forum Search
Advanced forum search



Latest Posts

New Atkins Dieter Using Fat Secret for Net Carbs Tracking - Suggestions Appreciated
Thank you, mummydee. You are right. Must stay AT 20. I am usually going a bit over...I eat kefir (plain) with my nuts, and that is a bit higher in carbs. In fact from what I have read it is really just ...
by auroraioanid on 27 Feb 15 08:05 PM
menopause & post and Atkins
I completely agree with the Atkins/paleo/ ketogenic way of eating during menopause. The cleaner the foods the easier it is, at least that's what I experienced and have read many other posts where ...
by mummydee on 27 Feb 15 04:12 PM
1200 calories diet, or have I miscalculated badly?
its easier for us to see in your food diary, because there is has a auto breakdown and fats, protein, carbs etc
by howzat4u on 27 Feb 15 02:46 PM
HOW TO POST PICTURES ON F.S.
HOW TO UPLOAD PICTURE INTO F.S. Let me see if I can help you.... You can either go to free images on the web, or use your own photo file site. Then select an image that you may like. Right click-Hit Save ...
by Ann444 on 27 Feb 15 01:56 PM
For those of you following Weight Watchers and using Fat Secret...
Hi Robyn - I joined Fatsecret a little over two years ago. At the time I was doing Weight Watchers, and for several months I did "double entry" - put my food into the log here and also a sp ...
by jwill77nc2 on 27 Feb 15 01:30 PM

Member Tip

average member ranking
by member Tresmemphis
Drink water
13 Feb 15 for diet Atkins