Atkins vs South Beach

previous topic · next topic
S-lady

Joined: Mar 09
Posts: 14

      quote  
Posted: 06 Mar 2009, 16:50
I know there must be some of you who have tried both diets or a combination of the two. What are the real differences between the two diets? Seems people lose an average of .7 pounds per week regardless of which diet: WW, Atkins, or South Beach.Question

I'm starting my first two weeks of Atkins on March 9. We are attending a benefit dinner this Saturday so I decided to wait until Monday to start. My real challenge(s) is the fact that I live in Costa Rica and have been eating A LOT of fruit up until now. There's so much fruit available here year round and it's so CHEAP! Have to get over that. My 2nd challenge is that there are very, very few diet foods available here. For example: only 2 kinds of diet Jello, no low-fat cheeses, no Stevia, etc.Wink
One more question: how do I know whether the avocados we get here are CA or FL avocados? There seems to be a big difference in carb content between the two. TIA
S-lady
<a href="http://www.fatsecret.com/member/S-lady"><img src="http://www.fatsecret.com/ticker/S-lady.gif"></img></a>
mleh

Joined: Mar 09
Posts: 7

      quote  
Posted: 06 Mar 2009, 23:02
I have done both diets in the past and found Atkins too restrictive. South Beach was easier for me. I love onions and tomatoes and nuts which were all OK on SB but not on Atkins. There are other diets that encourage you to eat fruits....but if it is Atkins, you should look for haas avocados--the smaller ones with the bumpy skin rather than the larger smooth skinned ones. I did like the Adkins shakes but the bars were not very tasty to me. You can probably have the shakes shipped to you. I hope this is helpful and I wish you buena suerte!
S-lady

Joined: Mar 09
Posts: 14

      quote  
Posted: 08 Mar 2009, 08:52
Thanks mleh. Unfortunately, the avocados we get here in Costa Rica are the larger smooth skinned ones with black skins. I sometimes see the green-skinned ones. I plan on following the strict Atkins for the first two weeks and may then switch over to South Beach. I will be spending 2 weeks in FL in May and I remember there's lots of South Beach menu choices in restaurants there to help me during that time. I do plan on bringing lots of things back to CR with me so I'll look for the shakes (are they dry mixes?) Can't afford to have anything shipped here. Customs looks at the value of the package, adds the postage (Big$$), and then adds 40% of the total amount as duty. Example $20 value + $10 shipping + $30 so another $12 in duty plus additional taxes: fuel surcharge, etc adds up to a whopping cost!
S-lady
<a href="http://www.fatsecret.com/member/S-lady"><img src="http://www.fatsecret.com/ticker/S-lady.gif"></img></a>
cokezero1982

Joined: Jul 08
Posts: 54

      quote  
Posted: 09 Mar 2009, 12:41
Tomatoes, onions and nuts are all ok on atkins. on inductio nuts aren't, but many vegetables are. i would just google and inductions food list. i looooved atkins but didn't like south beach. on south beach i felt really restricted. on atkins there was an atkins way to make almost any product i'd normally want, and since i'm a creative cook i never got bored. south beach focused too much on mixing in low fat foods and it was terribly bland and boring. i like ground beef, darn it! the induction phase of atkins is more restrictive but as you come out of it you add in more and more foods.
"A man is but the product of his thoughts. What he thinks, he becomes."
-Gandhi
Chynah

Joined: Mar 09
Posts: 18

      quote  
Posted: 01 Apr 2009, 16:22
You should get the book. Dr. Atkins New Diet Revolution. I saw it on Amazon.com yesterday for only a penny. There are so many things in the book that you wouldn't evevn think to ask. Make sure to read it from cover to cover. Good Luck!
Carbs are the devil in disguise
adfafaa

Joined: Oct 08
Posts: 12

      quote  
Posted: 09 Apr 2009, 12:30
I'd say the main difference between south beach and Atkins is the understanding of how the body works. Atkins is based on scientific biological understanding of how the body works, and indeed how our bodies have evolved. High fat, high protein foods are how our bodies have evolved to eat. Our paleolithic ancestors didn't have access to low fat cheese and whatever else South Beach recommends. Atkins follows the understanding that fat is a natural energy source for our bodies, not to be avoided, where as south beach advocates lower fat.

Personally any diet that advocates lowering carbohydrate is going to get a thumbs up from me because it will help regulate carving and insulin imbalances but i find Atkins much easier to stick to and much more satisfying. The induction is tough but once through it, i find it so fun and easy, i have really enjoyed creating low carb version of my fave foods. Actually i've lost 35lbs on the atkins but recently stalled so i'm back on the induction to hopefully kick start the loss again. Good luck with your WAE xx



Forum Search
Advanced forum search



Latest Posts

High carb- Low protein and HUNGRY all the time???
You can, simply do your research, combine your plant proteins. Most sources I've checked over the years say women need at least around 46grams a day, men around 56. Livestrong has a formula for ca ...
by wholefoodnut on 20 Sep 14 04:41 AM
Fed Up (2014) Documentary
nb girl wrote: 7Priest7, did you actually see the movie? Yes nb girl wrote: The movie showed a 6 month old baby who is obese, you could argue the mother is overfeeding the baby, but as the obstetrician ...
by 7Priest7 on 19 Sep 14 09:45 PM
Health sidekick
Yup looked into it too and it doesn't follow the golden rule of KISS (keep it simple stupid) It was confusing, plus the food data base was weird. MFS is global and they have done a great job of ...
by AKRSAR on 19 Sep 14 06:39 PM
Eliminating Sugar - Where do you draw the line?
Ruhu wrote: I know not all agree that eliminating sugar is the way to go for us self-proclaimed sugar addicts, but it truly works best for me. I've found time & time again that for me, one bite ...
by rolandbaranek on 19 Sep 14 12:57 PM
exercise
If adding it yourself is too much, go to the exercise list. There are calisthenics in 2 or 3 levels as well as yoga (for stretching type things). I use the light calisthenics since I do them at home and ...
by msbuggirl on 19 Sep 14 11:48 AM

Member Tip

average member ranking
by member Lucky765
This is tough......I,m spending 90% of my time trying to stay on meal plan and the other 10% going off it.....Resulting in an increase in weight..
05 Jan 14 for diet Atkins