Body composition analyzer

previous topic · next topic
Nia140

Joined: Sep 12
Posts: 16

      quote  
Posted: 06 Mar 2013, 08:19
Yesterday I did my second weigh-in exactly one week after my initial weigh-in before I started exercising and eating healthy. My results may be a little skewed because the first weigh-in my height was entered as 5"3 1/2 and my second weigh-in my heigh was 5'4".

But her are my results:

Weight: Went from 167.4 to 163.6.
BMR: From 1454 to 1507
Fat %: From 38.8 to 33.8
Fat Mass: 65lb to 55.4 lb
FFM: 102.4 to 108.21
TBW: 75.01 to 79.21

So what does this mean? He told me that I lost 10 lbs of fat and gained 6 lb of muscle. That seems pretty drastic for a week!
shmiller

Joined: Mar 10
Posts: 504

      quote  
Posted: 06 Mar 2013, 08:34
Yeah, your body fat percentage loss seems pretty dramatic for a single week. How did he calculate your body fat loss? Calipers? Water submersion? That electronic thingy (the name is escaping me) that you hold in your hands? Are you paying this guy?

Not to discredit your losses or make light of your progress. Every step matters. I just hate to see people misled about fitness and weight loss. We're already vulnerable enough.
"The grass ain't greener, the wine ain't sweeter, either side of the hill" The Grateful Dead
Nia140

Joined: Sep 12
Posts: 16

      quote  
Posted: 06 Mar 2013, 08:46
I used the electronic things you hold in your hands. No I am not paying him- I'm not sure how that is relevant as my results would be the same regardless of whether I was or wasn't.

I used the Tanita Body Composition Analyzer. Also, my height was entered a 1/2 inch shorter than the first weigh-in (not his fault though).
shmiller

Joined: Mar 10
Posts: 504

      quote  
Posted: 06 Mar 2013, 13:17
Don't misunderstand, I'm not trying to offend you. I just wondered, as I thought you did, about the accuracy of your results (or, maybe you were just celebrating your drastic change, it's hard to tell.)

Often, shady trainers or weightloss "coaches" who do our analysis for us (and whom we are paying) get results that are vastly different from reality because they need to show progress. If you don't progress, you won't keep coming and won't keep paying. This is especially true if your numbers on the scale drop very little or not at all; to say that you've lost body fat (which the average person can't always measure for themselves as they can their own weight) seems convincingly like progress. You didn't identify who "he" was and it seemed to me if you were indeed questioning "his" accuracy (even given a misstep in terms of height), it might be worth considering whether "he" (a paid analyzer) could be setting you up for disappointment.
"The grass ain't greener, the wine ain't sweeter, either side of the hill" The Grateful Dead



Forum Search
Advanced forum search



Latest Posts

Changing password
Jane! How you do change the password on this crazy thing! JANE!
by Tangent Z on 01 Nov 14 05:53 AM
Calorie Counting
I need a buddy!!!
by kristihorosz on 31 Oct 14 08:29 PM
Cornerstone Wellness Program
I've just started the Cornerstone Wellness program so will try to post back as results become known. To respond to Hoser: just can't seem to do it totally on my own any more. In past times I ...
by RiverSong46 on 31 Oct 14 01:38 PM
NO Scales
I have decided to weigh once a month...only. A very hard decision since I am so determined and desperate to lose weight.
by jocanoga on 31 Oct 14 12:36 PM
meat
I found a salad with a can of Tuna in water, satisfies me for a need of protein. Th Tuna is only 90 calories; less the Greek yogurt I used to have. That being said, a BBQ grilled lean meat is hard to beat ...
by jb007 on 31 Oct 14 07:13 AM