Getting a good scale

previous topic · next topic

Joined: Nov 12
Posts: 7

Posted: 13 Nov 2012, 18:08
So yesterday i weighed myself, and then today I weighed myself at approximately the same time as the day before and i gained 3 pounds. Now I know that different things play into weight loss/gain like going to the bathroom and how heavy your clothes are, but I feel like it shouldn't change by 3 lbs. Any suggestions on a good scale to purchase that is maybe more reliable?


Joined: Jul 10
Posts: 2,052

Posted: 13 Nov 2012, 18:23
Before you do that, a couple of things.

Are you weighing yourself on a solid, level floor? Don't put your scale on something soft like carpeting.

Second, try getting on and off the scale ten times in a row, giving the scale a few seconds to zero out between readings if necessary. Record each one, and see how consistent they are.

Joined: Jan 10
Posts: 521

Posted: 13 Nov 2012, 23:33
Consuming a meal the night before with a little extra salt can be one reason. Eating some extra starchy carbs can make you hold more water weight. If your female the week leading up to your time of month can cause significant water weight gain. A 3 lbs fluctuation isn't anything to worry about. Keep tracking your weight.... you'll see how it fluctuates. It's normal, don't panic. Stay strong Smile

Joined: Jul 11
Posts: 343

Posted: 14 Nov 2012, 01:16
I agree with the posts above. The scale accuracy is measured by weighing more times at the same time and if the readings are consistent ie within 0.2 pounds the scale is ok. Another test is to use a known weight as a benchmark ie weighing exercise weights and checking that the valus is correct.

3 pounds fluctuation between one day and the following is normal and that is one of the reason why I think it is not a great idea to weigh everyday.
I personally use an Omron scale with body fat monitor which is very accurate and relatively cheap.

Joined: Sep 11
Posts: 4

Posted: 14 Nov 2012, 05:01
probably water weight
Fitness Coach, check me out at
For Daily Fitness & Health Videos visit my youtube channel -

Joined: Feb 11
Posts: 1,223

Posted: 14 Nov 2012, 08:08
I agree - likely water weight vs extra stool in your system - clothing that you are wearing...

You could take a 5 lb bag of flour or sugar and weigh - if it says 5 lbs. then your scale is likely accurate. Sometimes you need something heavier, like 10 lbs - then you could use 2 bags or a set of handweights.

Forum Search
Advanced forum search

Latest Posts

Branded food not in the fatsecret database
rhills wrote: Hope you get a response! I want to add Sustainable Seas Solid Light Tuna in Water No Salt Added. There is already one without the "No Salt Added" -- and it has twice the sodium. ...
by Jean Mc on 29 Mar 17 03:29 PM
Brilliant. Thanks for the information, puts things in perspective.
by slimit on 28 Mar 17 07:14 PM
Qsymia anyone?
If everyone found it easy to "get a grip" then logically very few people would be overweight. If a person feels like they need a pill to help them start on their journey and their doctor b ...
by slimit on 28 Mar 17 05:49 PM
5:2 diet
Hi marymcin, 5:2 is [url= Fast Diet [/url]by Dr Michael Mosely. Essentially, two days a week you fast - fast days (FDs). This means eating a maximum of 500 calories (for ...
by Jean Mc on 28 Mar 17 04:18 PM
Have you gotten well and off the steroids?
by TomLong on 28 Mar 17 04:05 PM