Heart Rate monitor question

previous topic · next topic

Joined: May 10
Posts: 244

Posted: 21 Aug 2012, 16:17
I just need some clarification!... i've based my exercise/calorie burn information on the estimates on generic calculators or using MFP/Fatsecret for a long time. I finally got a HRM and it seems to calculate my calories burned at a higher rate than any of my other calculators have estimated. I have always low-balled my exercise for fear of under performing and over estimating... should i go by my HRM which is based on what i'm actually doing?

Joined: Jan 12
Posts: 275

Posted: 21 Aug 2012, 16:44
whoa! you have the opposite problem I do. FS overestimates compared to my heart rate monitor. I guess, if it's calibrated correctly for your height/weight & taking accurate HR, I'd go by it!

Joined: May 10
Posts: 244

Posted: 21 Aug 2012, 17:22
@ jess i'm not sure if its from years of always underestimating out of fear and now seeing an actual number? or if something is wrong!.. i've always pushed hard... and i know its hard to calculate on these estimation calculators b/c i do a lot of intervals.. i don't know.. i guess i'll work with it!

Joined: Feb 11
Posts: 121

Posted: 22 Aug 2012, 06:48
Go by your heart rate monitor as long as it is calibrated properly to you. Ensure that as you lose weight you let your monitor know. The generic calculators are an average of many whereas the HRM is more specific to you and your HR. What makes one person's HR reach 150 may not make a more fit individual's reach it even though they weigh the same. Stay within your zone and don't go past it...you will burn more fat.

Joined: May 10
Posts: 244

Posted: 22 Aug 2012, 08:16
thank you preggo!

Forum Search
Advanced forum search

Latest Posts

I am stuck and cannot loose anymore weight!!!
I lost 17 lbs on Atkins, and had to change it up due to a plateau and the fact that my cholesterol was completely out of control and my pre-diabetic condition was getting worse instead of better. I now ...
by catkane8662 on 23 Aug 16 08:58 PM
Linking FS to Apple Health
Hi I have been using MFP for a few years but it's reliability has been off for a while now and FS has been recommended as the best alternative. I'm having a bit of a problem with linking it to ...
by j_b78 on 23 Aug 16 02:43 PM
FatSecret Settings - Activity Level vs. Recorded Excercise
You are supposed to choose sedentary. I don't know if you put your mouse to the right of the 4 possibilities but it explained what they cover. It is meant for the type of work that you do only and ...
by Charlotte_15 on 18 Aug 16 12:19 AM
Niacin bound chromium
I stay away from anything other than natural. I'd rather spend my money on good foods rather than line the pockets of the too many who prey off this emotional issue. I'm 10-12% bodyfat. I eat zero ...
by adamevegod on 09 Aug 16 11:52 AM
I also use to eat small meals 4-5 times a day, and try to control my carbs as much as I can do, although I didn't cut it completely but dropped it up to a reasonable level, and also using beyond w ...
by daisytaylor2405 on 07 Aug 16 06:07 AM