Body Fat Percentage - Scales Vs. Calipers

previous topic · next topic
NCNOLE

Joined: Feb 11
Posts: 1,218

      quote  
Posted: 11 Mar 2012, 13:56
Couldn't find any info on the forums on this, so here goes. I was just wondering if anyone has the scales that calculate body fat % and has also done the skin caliper test.
I'm wondering how close they actually were. An acquaintance told me hers was only off by 1%. The reason I ask is that over the past 9 months, I have gradually gotten my BF% down from 32% to 20% and I just can't imagine that I have only 20% BF. I work out 1-2 hours daily but just don't feel like my body looks tight - like I would expect a female w/ 20% BF to look Smile
Thaylin

Joined: Mar 12
Posts: 3

      quote  
Posted: 11 Mar 2012, 15:05
really I think the best thing is to go get a hydrostatic test done. It is the only accurate way to test that.
coachcj8

Joined: May 11
Posts: 382

      quote  
Posted: 12 Mar 2012, 01:17
I'm not sure how accurate scales are to skin fold caliper tests. I don't know how a scale would be able to tell what the body composition is of the person standing on it. Just a couple months ago I had the hydrostatic body fat done. It's the one where you are weighed in water. It's done to within 1.5% accuracy. It was awesome! It is like $40 but well worth it in my opinion. In November I had my bf measurement done with the caliper an I was 27%. At the end of February I was 21.7% in the tub. I think the caliper must have been off quite a bit.
Cort
paperiniko

Joined: Jul 11
Posts: 343

      quote  
Posted: 12 Mar 2012, 04:56
the scales that have body monitors are quite good to show the trend, their precisiono depends on a number of factors such as the model of course and the person. Generally the error can be higher for women than for men and I have read that for the best models it is +-4% so you might expect an actual BF in the range of 16-24%.

Calipers also are not superaccurate because they depend on the ability of the persons taking the measures.

In the end the most important thing is to monitor whether your BF is decreasing or increasing so I do not think that having a measure that is accurate to within 1% should be a priority also because the same body fat percentage can "look" different on different people. 20% or so for a woman seems pretty good actually and maybe slightly on the high side for a man.
fredmugs

Joined: Jan 11
Posts: 382

      quote  
Posted: 12 Mar 2012, 07:38
Forget trying to track your body fat %. Anything you use is either not consistently reliable or subjective. As I understand it even the weigh yourself in water method will vary depending on your level of hydration at the time.
Pain is a by-product of a good time.
JessWhatINee...

Joined: Jan 12
Posts: 273

      quote  
Posted: 12 Mar 2012, 14:16
I have a scale that does it. Bioelectrical Impedance or something like that. How they work (to my understanding) you nave to be barefoot and not have eaten or drank for 3 hours before or it will throw it off. An electric pulse wave is sent up thru your body. You don't feel anything. And since fat has a difference density than water/other tissue the rate it travels can be measured to determine the body fat %.
Mine varies between 35% and 37% on my scale. I got it done professionally in a bodpod and it was 35%. I'd say the scale is accurate. But I really hate to admit it b/c that makes me obese and I feel like I'm in decent shape!
Helewis

Joined: Jan 11
Posts: 339

      quote  
Posted: 12 Mar 2012, 14:42
Yep, Jess. I have the same. I have a Tanita Ironman BC-554. And you explained it perfectly. Hydration is also key in addition to when you weigh. I think they're great, but mine is a little more expensive than others. My scale has a regular mode and an athlete's mode. When I got it last May I was at 51% bf, now I'm about 29%. Working on building up the muscle on mine.



Forum Search
Advanced forum search



Latest Posts

Calorie Counting
I need a buddy!!!
by kristihorosz on 31 Oct 14 08:29 PM
Cornerstone Wellness Program
I've just started the Cornerstone Wellness program so will try to post back as results become known. To respond to Hoser: just can't seem to do it totally on my own any more. In past times I ...
by RiverSong46 on 31 Oct 14 01:38 PM
NO Scales
I have decided to weigh once a month...only. A very hard decision since I am so determined and desperate to lose weight.
by jocanoga on 31 Oct 14 12:36 PM
meat
I found a salad with a can of Tuna in water, satisfies me for a need of protein. Th Tuna is only 90 calories; less the Greek yogurt I used to have. That being said, a BBQ grilled lean meat is hard to beat ...
by jb007 on 31 Oct 14 07:13 AM
after dinner eating
Incidentally, Nutella is not that bad but the question is, can you stop at one spoonful. I can't :-)
by jennyhenrick1 on 31 Oct 14 06:29 AM