previous topic · next topic

Joined: Jan 08
Posts: 520

Posted: 18 Aug 2012, 12:08
I had a Labrador Retriever that lived to eat. You had to measure out her food for the day - you couldn't just leave a bowl full of food out and expect her to eat what she needed. And when she did eat, an entire bowl of dry food was inhaled in less than a minute!

One time, she got into her 40 lb bag of dog food when we weren't home (after that we stored it in a plastic bin). She must have eaten about 10 lbs of food. I came home, not knowing what she had got into, and noticed she was panting really heavy and that she was literally bulging at the sides to the point where her fur was standing on end. I thought there was something medically wrong with her and took her to the vet. An x-ray and $80 later, the vet asked me "did she just have a very large meal?"

So... what was that you were saying about animals feeding instinctively for survival? LOL Laughing



Joined: Apr 12
Posts: 78

Posted: 18 Aug 2012, 15:54
Animals do not simply eat enough for survival and then stop. Animals, from humans all the way down, will eat as much as is available. In the wild, peak hunting seasons do not last long enough nor are they abundant enough that hunting animals can get fat or stay that way for long. Among modern industrialized humans and our domestic pets, the peak hunting season never ends.

Humans have striven since the dawn of their existence to live in the world we have created -- a world where food is plentiful, where people live long productive lives, and where physical security is almost guaranteed. You're alarmed by this?!? I consider myself lucky to live in Paradise on Earth.

If a couple of generations of obesity is the price our species pays to learn how to balance our old biological desires and our new comfortable needs, I think that's a bargain. We must eat to live, but why shouldn't we occasionally enjoy the hard fought benefit of living to eat?

Joined: May 12
Posts: 117

Posted: 18 Aug 2012, 17:38
"I disagree with the notion that plentiful food has anything to do with longevity. The fewer calories a person consumes over their lifetime, the higher the probability that they will live a longer life"

This most certainly needs to be qualified. Obviously the quality of the food consumed is also a criterion. With abundance and plentiful food comes choice as well, and being able to choose the quality of calories. That must have something to do with longevity. You don't live long or well on, as an example ,just white rice.
Those who don't have choices or abundance would disagree with you.
The best measure of a man's honesty isn't his income tax return. It's the zero adjust on his bathroom scale.- Arthur C Clarke

Travel is fatal to prejudice, bigotry, and narrow-mindedness. - Mark Twain


Joined: Jul 12
Posts: 80

Posted: 19 Aug 2012, 20:23
Many caloric restriction trials on animals have shown significantly increased lifespans. The literature is abundant.

re: wild animals, I would add that overweight animals would not be as fit, and suffer increased predation. Probable evolutionary feedback as well.
dx w/inoperable brain tumor 9/12, so nutrition is vital. Dedicated to slaying this beast.

"Keep on swimming" Nemo

Joined: Jun 12
Posts: 12

Posted: 19 Aug 2012, 20:34
Really enjoyed this conversation..and has definitely given me something to think out about. Thanks for sharing your opinions!!!

Forum Search
Advanced forum search

Latest Posts

Lemon Sole Fillets Served in Mushroom Sauce
Steam ovens are said to be the best cooking appliances for their use of steam in cooking thus eliminating the use of oil or even butter. If you are a seafood lover, you can try out some lemon sole fillets ...
by Sally Wilkinson on 30 Nov 15 11:48 PM
I get my chocolate "fix" by making with Stevia: chocolate pudding, hot cocoa using organic fat free milk (it is just as creamy as 2% milk with a long shelf life) I plan to experiment with cocoa ...
by changeovertime on 30 Nov 15 06:13 PM
I'm a backslider!
@Phil... and mind. I'm a completely different person on keto. My mood is so bad off, I even lose my tickle spots. Literally! My brain is so foggy that I can't even remember VERY important appo ...
by FatGirlJenny on 30 Nov 15 06:01 PM
Any activity trackers that sync with FatSecret?
I'm debating on buying a FitBit Charge HR or a Jawbone Up3. I wish there was a tracker which would feed the activity to my FatSecret.
by srizvi1 on 30 Nov 15 12:11 PM
I've been making entries to weight on a weekly schedule and I have missed some. However, the last oh 4-6 entries are not showing up. Not sure what I'm doing wrong. I am going to try and enter them ...
by Spiritual Life on 30 Nov 15 09:53 AM