Can you gain 2 pounds in one day?

previous topic · next topic
roziebee

Joined: Mar 13
Posts: 8

      quote  
Posted: 04 Apr 2013, 11:44
I went on the scale first thing Wednesday morning and I weight 182 I measured myself and I had lost one inch but no weight. First thingt this morning I weighed myself and I weighed 184. I only had 1538 calories the day before. Is that possible, to gain 2 pounds in one day with only 1538 calories? I know I did not gain any muscle because I have not been able to wk out due to an injury, but I dropped my calories by 200 to make up for that.I am still a inch smaller thank God.
Nimm

Joined: Dec 10
Posts: 669

      quote  
Posted: 04 Apr 2013, 12:23
It's trivially easy to gain 2 pounds of weight in a day. Drink a glass of water and you can get a pound right there. If your glycogen is low because you're following a lower-carbohydrate diet (or did some exercise recently), and you have a higher-carb day, you can add a couple pounds of glycogen immediately.

This isn't weight worth worrying about though - you're probably concerned about body fat, not just "weight." And on that point, it is theoretically possible to add 2 pounds of fat in one day, but impossible as a practical matter. You would have to consume over 7000 calories more than you burned.

If your weight increases that much overnight, and you did not go on massive eating binge, you can rest assured it is not body fat. Just normal bodyweight and scale "noise" masking the measure of actual body fat levels.

Total weight can increase while body fat decreases, and vice versa. The amount of misery and confusion caused by equating scale weight with body fat is one of the biggest problems with weight management, in my opinion. Don't read too much into each day's weigh-in. Look for the long-term trends.
roziebee

Joined: Mar 13
Posts: 8

      quote  
Posted: 04 Apr 2013, 14:52
Thanks for the good advice. It was very helpful



Forum Search
Advanced forum search



Latest Posts

Do you guys track fruit?
Log everything if calorie counting is new and adherence to diet/results are not perfect/expected. If you *honestly* know you can keep a mental count that is accurate then perhaps it's okay to stop ...
by fattymcfattyson on 26 Sep 16 06:00 PM
Coffee good for weight loss?
I have been a coffee drinker for years. I still put on the weight so I really do no think it helps weight loss unless you drink too much and it makes you sick.
by slemo58 on 26 Sep 16 05:45 PM
Can't seem to stick to a diet
Oh there is certainly pleasure aspect in food, but it needs to be within the wider perspective of fuel/nutrition needed for the body. This is why iifym is a good method. I was merely providing a possible ...
by SoMuchBS on 26 Sep 16 05:44 PM
Stubborn Fat
yea, spot reduction is total bogosity. Its entirely genetic where your body pulls, or puts fat.
by jeffpa on 26 Sep 16 01:01 PM
Industry funded studies
Hi, Titedancer, thats a great story. the diet your husband seems to be following is called Ketosis. it when your body starts to target fat as its primary fuel source and the liver turns fat cell into ...
by jodymcconnachie on 26 Sep 16 06:55 AM